Pipe17 President Kelly Goetsch on personal AI agents like Meta’s Muse, where AI helps shoppers, and why Google keeps confusing buying with shopping.
Kelly Goetsch can make a restaurant reservation in about 30 seconds. So, when Meta's Muse and other personal AI agents offer to do it for him, the President of Pipe17 says they're solving a problem he doesn't have.
Recorded live and in person at RetailClub AI Festival in Huntington Beach, this episode of Retail Transformers sits down with Kelly Goetsch, President of Pipe17, co-founder of the MACH Alliance, and founder of the Commerce Operations Foundation. Ricardo Belmar and Casey Golden ask him whether he'd trust personal AI agents with his data, where AI is helping shoppers in agentic commerce today, and why he doesn't see Google winning this one.
What You'll Learn in This Episode:
Kelly's three problems with personal AI agents like Meta's Muse and Instinct.
Why an AI agent is only as useful as the sites that let it in.
Why Kelly wants one agent, and why he doesn't expect to get one.
What Kelly actually wants help with (it involves dry cleaning).
The agentic commerce use case Kelly says works today: human-led discovery.
Why letting AI buy your next suit is a terrible use case, and what to ask it instead.
Kelly's prediction for where shoppers will use AI this holiday season (jump to 13:21).
How Kelly thinks we'll look back on this moment in a year or two (jump to 13:06).
Why Kelly says Google confuses buying with shopping.
With Black Friday less than a week away, this is the agentic commerce conversation to hear before you hand anything to an AI agent.
Subscribe & Follow.
Don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe to The Retail Razor: Retail Transformers for more episodes featuring retail innovators, disruptors, and bold thinkers reshaping commerce.
Subscribe to the Retail Razor Podcast Network: https://retailrazor.com/
Subscribe to our Newsletter: https://retailrazor.substack.com
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://go.retailrazor.com/utube
About Our Guest.
Kelly Goetsch. https://www.linkedin.com/in/kellygoetsch/
President, Pipe17. https://pipe17.com
Kelly Goetsch is President at Pipe17. Previously, as CPO and CSO at commercetools, he helped grow revenue from $2M to $200M over 8.5 years. Before that, he led product management for microservices initiatives at Oracle and was a senior architect at ATG (acquired by Oracle), where he oversaw all of Walmart's global ATG implementations.
Kelly co-founded the MACH Alliance, a 121-vendor consortium including Google Cloud, AWS, Stripe, and Deloitte. He is founder and president of The Commerce Operations Foundation, an 86-member vendor consortium defining the agentic commerce interface to fulfillment. The foundation's open source standard, the Order Network eXchange (onX), is being adopted by leading OMSes, 3PLs, and WMSes. Together, member vendors process over $1 trillion in GMV.
He is the author of four O'Reilly books on commerce, microservices, and cloud architecture. He holds a BS in Entrepreneurship and an MS in Management Information Systems from the University of Illinois at Chicago, along with three patents including one key to distributed computing.
Chapters.
(00:00) Teaser
(00:29) Show Intro
(02:57) Would You Trust Meta's New AI Agent With Your Data?
(08:53) Why Nobody Needs an AI Agent (We Want a Robot Instead)
(10:05) The AI Use Case in Commerce That Actually Works
(13:21) What Shoppers Will Do With AI This Holiday Season
(14:39) Why Google Will Lose Agentic Commerce
(16:13) Show Close
Meet Your Hosts.
Helping you stay sharp, be bold, and transform retail:
Ricardo Belmar is an NRF Top Retail Voice for 2025 and a RETHINK Retail Top Retail Expert from 2021 – 2026 and a Top AI Leader for 2027. Thinkers 360 has named him a Top 10 Thought Leader in Retail and eCommerce, a Top 25 Thought Leader inCareers, a Top 50 Thought Leader in Agentic AI, AGI and Management, and a Top 100 Thought Leader in AI Ethics, Marketing, Digital Transformation and Transformation. Thinkers 360 also awarded him an Elite Expert Certification in Retail, a Master Expert Certification in Management, and named him a Certified Expert in AI, Marketing, and Digital Transformation. Thinkers 360 also named him a Top Digital Voice for 2024, 2025 and 2026. He is an advisory council member at the Retail Cloud Alliance. He was most recently the partner marketing leader for retail & consumer goods in the Americas at Microsoft.
Casey Golden, is the North America Leader for Retail & Consumer Goods at CI&T, and CEO of Luxlock. She is a RETHINK Retail Top Retail Expert from 2023 - 2026, and Retail Cloud Alliance advisory council member. After a career on the fashion and supply chain technology side of the business, Casey is obsessed with the customer relationship between the brand and the consumer and is slaying franken-stacks and building retail tech!
Episode Music.
Includes music provided by imunobeats.com, featuring Tropikool, from the album Future Beats 2, plus Virtual Apology and New Styles, from the album Shimmer Pop, written by Heston Mimms, published by Imuno.
Highlight Clips.
[00:04:47] - And I've I've two issues with it. First issue is I don't really have that many digital tasks. Like, I find it pretty easy to go…
[00:15:22] - Right. I I don't see... I honestly don't see Google lot of retail people building tech in the first place. Fair enough. I…
[00:08:57] - You need to watch some of it. Yeah. There is one episode where you get a little mini you, and you have to beat it into…
Transcript.
S2E14 Kelly Goetsch on Personal AI Agents & Agentic Commerce
[00:00:00] Teaser
[00:00:00]
[00:00:01] Ricardo Belmar: Meta's Muse is racking up downloads and personal AI agents are everywhere. Kelly Goetsch, president of Pipe17, says they're solving a problem he doesn't have
[00:00:12] Casey Golden: He can book a dinner reservation in 30 seconds. What he really wants is a robot to pick up his dry cleaning
[00:00:18] Ricardo Belmar: This episode of Retail Transformers recorded live from RetailClub AI Festival, Kelly explains where AI's actually helping shoppers and why Google keeps confusing buying with shopping
[00:00:29] Show Intro
[00:00:37] Ricardo Belmar: Welcome to Retail Transformers, candid conversations with the visionaries shaping the future of commerce.
[00:00:43] I'm Ricardo Belmar
[00:00:44] Casey Golden: And I'm Casey Golden. Welcome back, Retail Razor fans. This is the podcast where we cut through the clutter to bring you the sharpest insights from the leaders redefining retail, retail careers, and the future of retailing
[00:00:57] Ricardo Belmar: This is season two, episode [00:01:00] 14, and it's coming to you live and in person from the RetailClub AI Festival in Huntington Beach, where we spoke with Kelly Goetsch, president of Pipe17, in our Retail Razor Tent studio.
[00:01:10] Casey Golden: If you've worked in commerce tech, you know Kelly's work. Chief product officer and chief strategy officer at Commercetools. He helped grow revenue from two million to $200 million. He co-founded the MACH Alliance, and today he leads the Commerce Operations Foundation, which is building an open standard for how AI agents connect to fulfillment with the Order Network Exchange
[00:01:38] Ricardo Belmar: We started the conversation with Meta's Muse and the new wave of personal agents. Well, Kelly has three problems with those. First, they solve a problem he doesn't have. He wants anything with his name on it to be deterministic, and he isn't handing his private data to companies he doesn't trust. Meanwhile, the sites these agents depend on, well, they're pushing back. Amazon's already blocked [00:02:00] Muse from buying on its store, and plenty of other sites are putting up walls for personal agents. Just as this is going to publish, I just read that eBay is now blocking Muse, too. Kelly's point, an agent is only as useful as the places that let it in
[00:02:13] Casey Golden: Yeah. I mean, tech and trust, kind of an oxymoron. so we get to where Kelly says AI really helps human-led discovery. Finding the right replacement part, the right cleaner for a wool carpet, or the right fabric for a summer suit. Don't just let it buy the suit for you
[00:02:35] Ricardo Belmar: Plus, Kelly's prediction for holiday shopping with AI and why he doesn't see Google winning this one because, well, Google keeps confusing buying with shopping every time they get into commerce.
[00:02:46] Now let's welcome Kelly Goetsch of Pipe17 to Retail Transformers
[00:02:51]
[00:02:57] Would You Trust Meta's New AI Agent With Your Data?
[00:02:57] Ricardo Belmar: And we are back in our tent in [00:03:00] RetailClub, and today we're joined by Kelly Goetsch, the president of Pipe17. Kelly, thanks so much for joining us today and chatting with us.
[00:03:06] Kelly Goetsch: Thank you for having me.
[00:03:07] Casey Golden: Yeah. welcome, welcome.
[00:03:09] Ricardo Belmar: So it's an AI conference, of course.
[00:03:11] Kelly Goetsch: I've heard.
[00:03:11] Ricardo Belmar: So, yeah, you may have heard. So big surprise, we're gonna talk about all things AI.
[00:03:16] Kelly Goetsch: Okay.
[00:03:16] Ricardo Belmar: And, I, I feel like if there's anything I'd say if I were to describe you, Kelly, to anyone, probably one of the first things I'd say is that you have quite a few thoughts on where things are headed around use of AI, how it's gonna affect commerce what kinds of things people should expect to happen, what things you might be surprised about.
[00:03:33] So I think maybe just to start with something really timely that's been in the news, we're once again talking about personal agents because Meta released Muse, and I don't understand it myself, but somehow it's like the number-one download in all the app stores. So people are trying. I know you at least tried it maybe out of curiosity.
[00:03:52] but I know, I haven't tried it because I don't know, I don't feel like I can trust them enough to do these kinds of things for me given Meta's [00:04:00] history in so many different ways. So...
[00:04:01] Casey Golden: I sense
[00:04:01] Kelly Goetsch: Wait, you mean they're a dishonest company?
[00:04:04] I mean- Is that what you're implying?
[00:04:05] Ricardo Belmar: I might... maybe implying something.
[00:04:07] I, I don't know.
[00:04:08] Yeah. mean, if, if I'm gonna make the list of companies I would trust to take all of my personal information and go do things for me, I don't think they'd top the list. That's true. I just have a sense that they wouldn't. So, but I'm... What do you think about all this?
[00:04:21] Kelly Goetsch: So M- Muse, there's another one called Instinct as well.
[00:04:25] Instinct. Yeah. similar concept. and what they are is personal assistants. So think of it as OpenClaw, if you know, or, -
[00:04:30] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah ...
[00:04:31] Kelly Goetsch: think of it as your, voice mode on your, ChatGPT or your Claude, basically. And in theory at least, it'll go out and make reservations for you, it'll buy things for you- yeah ... it'll help manage your calendar. Like, in theory at least, it should be doing, personal assistant-type tasks.
[00:04:46] Casey Golden: Interesting.
[00:04:47] Kelly Goetsch: And i've, I have two issues with it. First issue is I don't really have that many digital tasks. Like, I find it pretty easy to go buy stuff these days.
[00:04:55] I can make reservations. I do
[00:04:57] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah. That's what
[00:04:58] Casey Golden: that all the time.
[00:04:59] Kelly Goetsch: Unnecessary.
[00:04:59] Casey Golden: It's It's not [00:05:00] that hard.
[00:05:00] Kelly Goetsch: It's solving a problem I don't have.
[00:05:02] So- the other, another challenge is just I want it to be deterministic. it's very important to me if my name is on something, that a message goes out to someone.
[00:05:11] Ricardo Belmar: Right.
[00:05:12] Right.
[00:05:12] Kelly Goetsch: I, i, i've seen how these can, be mistaken, and I don't want my name on something, high consequence. so that's another challenge. And then the third issue is, as you alluded, is just the, the risk of y- all of your private data in somebody else's hands.
[00:05:27] And- Instinct, for the record, is run by, founded and run by a 23-year-old. Not that I have anything against 23-year-olds.
[00:05:34] But he just fundraised at 2.5 billion a month ago, and he's now fundraising at 10 billion. 4X valuation in a month. And i'm sure, he's got his yacht and his, his place in Ibiza. And, yeah.I'm sure security is like number 62 on his prioritized list of things to worry about right now.
[00:05:53] Ricardo Belmar: Right.
[00:05:53] Kelly Goetsch: so I worry about that. And then I worry about, Meta just as a company. You know-
[00:05:57] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah ...
[00:05:58] Kelly Goetsch: honestly, they're, they have a [00:06:00] well-earned reputation for being deceitful- on a lot of levels not putting people first. they still run scam ads all the time because it generates
[00:06:07] Casey Golden: you know what?
[00:06:07] ......Revenue
[00:06:08] They can keep using the old data.
[00:06:11] Kelly Goetsch: Right
[00:06:11] Casey Golden: I didn't give I haven't given them any new data-
[00:06:13] Kelly Goetsch: So it's
[00:06:13] Casey Golden: for a very long time...
[00:06:14] Kelly Goetsch: so it's solving a problem I don't have with companies who I don't trust to do the right things with my data.
[00:06:21] And another challenge is, a lot of these companies that you work with, that Muse would use, are starting to block or have challenges with them.
[00:06:28] So resy yeah ...for reservations- ... is blocking folks, and that's becoming quite challenging. Amazon just yesterday blocked, Instinct ......... yeah ...and Muse-
[00:06:36] Ricardo Belmar: I heard, yeah ...
[00:06:37] Kelly Goetsch: from buying.
[00:06:37] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:06:38] Kelly Goetsch: So we're gonna... your o- your AI assistant is only as good as the things that allow, that you, that it are allowed to do. Right. the operators of all these platforms are very able to say, "No, we're not gonna let Instinct or Muse do anything with it
[00:06:51] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:06:51] Casey Golden: Yeah. Yeah. And it come ... it does have a lot to do, not just with, consumer trust- but brand trust, partner trust, ecosystem trust. [00:07:00] Like- right.
[00:07:00] Kelly Goetsch: And I don't switch from, I don't wanna have five different agents. I want one.
[00:07:04] And I'm probably not ever gonna get one 'cause there's gonna be an Amazon one, and then there's gonna be the Google one, and then and then there's gonna be the Claude one, and-
[00:07:11] Ricardo Belmar: And you're gonna end like we have with every technology before, that certain ones are
[00:07:14] Casey Golden: And I might as have the one that talks to those other agents.
[00:07:17] Kelly Goetsch: And I might as well just do it myself because I'm an adult and I can make a restaurant reservation in about 30 seconds
[00:07:22] Casey Golden: I know. I went to college and graduated with beautiful grades without chatGPT.
[00:07:28] Kelly Goetsch: exactly. It worked just fine, didn't It
[00:07:29] Casey Golden: I read the books.
[00:07:30] Ricardo Belmar: Exactly.
[00:07:31] Exactly.
[00:07:31] Exactly Yeah. Exactly. Exactly. Exactly. whole thing. Exactly. Yeah, there was a, I can't remember the name, but there was a tech journalist I saw posted on social media his test experience with Muse.
[00:07:41] I don't know if you saw this, but he mentioned that he was having a conversation via text with his editor about an upcoming project, and he was gonna use Muse to try to brainstorm some ideas because the article was gonna be about personal agents. And in the middle of the conversation, Muse says to him, "Well, maybe you could highlight this point that your editor mentioned in that last text message to you."[00:08:00]
[00:08:00] And, he wrote that he thought, and he said, "Well, wait a minute. How do you know that? I didn't give you access to my text messages. How do you know this?" And over the c- the conversation he had with Muse, he finds out that he had at one point told him it was okay to connect to his Mac apps for certain things.
[00:08:15] And once you did that, Muse told him that it had visibility to all of your notification streams on the Mac. And so it's not that it was reading his text message, but that one message that his editor had sent apparently had an image, and the whole image was in the notification. So it interpreted the text in the image automatically.
[00:08:31] Sneaky. and that's how he did it. So he ended up asking, " Oh, Well, when did I give you permission to read my notifications?"
[00:08:36] Kelly Goetsch: And I'm sure, you know what, in five years everyone will just do this by default, and gonna look at us and say, " okay, boomers," you know?
[00:08:43] Casey Golden: I know?
[00:08:43] Ricardo Belmar: I know, exactly.
[00:08:43] I right. And they're say
[00:08:44] Casey Golden: I do. feel like a boomer. I'm giving boomer. Yeah ... vibes lately. But, at the
[00:08:50] Ricardo Belmar: don't know thatthis particular app.
[00:08:52] Why Nobody Needs an AI Agent (We Want a Robot Instead)
[00:08:52] Casey Golden: you guys big fans of Black Mirror?
[00:08:55] Kelly Goetsch: I've never seen it. Mm. I've heard I should see
[00:08:57] Casey Golden: Heard it-
[00:08:57] You need to watch some of it. I've never seen it, yeah. There is one [00:09:00] episode where you get a little mini you. Okay. And you have to beat it into submission 'cause it doesn't understand that it's the mini you. So you do end up abusing your little mini me. Uh-huh.
[00:09:08] And it sits on the counter with, a little duplicate of your house. Mm-hmm. And then it starts running your life. And it's like your own little rice Krispie treat man, right?
[00:09:17] Kelly Goetsch: Yeah.
[00:09:17] Yeah.
[00:09:18] Casey Golden: Oh my gosh. That's what I want,
[00:09:19] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah, that's what you want, yeah.
[00:09:21] Kelly Goetsch: I want somebody to pick up my fucking dry cleaning. That's what I need help with. You know, like, physical things the world.
[00:09:27] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah. So, so you're gonna wait, Yeah ...you're waiting for the, consumer level humanoid robot to come and do work
[00:09:31] Kelly Goetsch: I want something to vacuum my room.
[00:09:33] Ricardo Belmar: Right.
[00:09:33] Kelly Goetsch: Something to empty my dishwasher.
[00:09:35] Casey Golden: Well- Yeah.
[00:09:35] Kelly Goetsch: That's what I need help
[00:09:36] Casey Golden: CES still can't, robots still can't fold a towel.
[00:09:39] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:09:40] Kelly Goetsch: They're getting awfully close for a lot of things
[00:09:42] Casey Golden: Yeah.
[00:09:42] Ricardo Belmar: But we just did an episode, right- Yeah ... too long ago with someone where his example was, that robot vacuum that's supposed to make our lives better by just cleaning for us, when it gets stuck, what it do? It sends a text message to my wife's phone- right- saying, " help, i'm stuck."
[00:09:54] How is this making our lives better?
[00:09:56] Kelly Goetsch: It is.. Not. No categorically not, no.
[00:09:58] And we had a Roomba years ago and just never [00:10:00] used it.
[00:10:00] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:10:00] Kelly Goetsch: got stuck all the time. Yeah, it got stuck. Yeah. It doesn't work, you might as well just do yourself.
[00:10:03] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah. You might as well do it. Yeah. Then get it unstuck.
[00:10:05] The AI Use Case in Commerce That Actually Works
[00:10:05] Ricardo Belmar: So what are the things you think do work that we're seeing in this agentic world? I, I know you've posted often about great things that you're finding you're able to do with AI that's helping you in your workday.
[00:10:16] Where do you think that this is... has potential to do something better for us w- in a commerce environment?
[00:10:21] where do you see the positive coming from?
[00:10:22] Kelly Goetsch: I think the biggest is human-led discovery.
[00:10:26] Mm. So I need a specific part, right? Uh-huh. Help me find this part, whatever this thing is, right? Mm-hmm. What is this spring?
[00:10:32] Where does it belong?
[00:10:33] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah
[00:10:33] Kelly Goetsch: How do I get another one of these things? Because that's where I struggle a lot of times.
[00:10:38] Yeah. how do you clean dog vomit out of carpet, you know? Suggest some products. Wool carpet, right?
[00:10:43] suggest some products for me. Mm-hmm. that's where I think AI is most helpful
[00:10:47] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah ...
[00:10:47] Kelly Goetsch: at this point. very good for consideration, top of funnel.
[00:10:51] I think we'll see over time, we'll see instant checkout come back or its equivalent, and I would then like to say, "Okay.
[00:10:57] Well, I'm an Amazon shopper," whatever. I [00:11:00] wanna click and buy that thing- mm-hmm ......and I want a wallet attached to my Claude or my ChatGPT where I can just buy the thing.
[00:11:05] that to me- ......... is utility.
[00:11:07] I don't see a ton of value in you know, another use case is okay, I need, a very specific bag of dog food on my door first of every month, right?
[00:11:15] Like, you could kind of see like a subscribe & save.
[00:11:17] I don't care where you source it from. Go figure it out.
[00:11:19] I want it. Like- that would be cool, but like I don't have that many of those things in my life on a daily basis that i... it really re- requires a lot of work.
[00:11:27] Ricardo Belmar: Mm-hmm.
[00:11:28] Kelly Goetsch: I I mean- Yeah we've got Amazon Subscribe & Save. You've got Chewy subscriptions. Right. like that's a relatively solved problem at this point.
[00:11:35] So I don't- really worry about that.
[00:11:37] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:11:37] Kelly Goetsch: And the third use case is more like it being proactive on your behalf.
[00:11:42] And like I don't want it deciding that I need a new watch and sending me a watch.
[00:11:45] Casey Golden: No.
[00:11:46] Kelly Goetsch: Right? And like there are very relatively few categories of where it ... wouldn't know that I stopped at an airport store and bought the thing.
[00:11:56] Right? Like relatively few... I want to be involved as a human- [00:12:00] is what I want.
[00:12:02] most of my goods are, either they're unconsidered,
[00:12:04] right? And it's
[00:12:05] Casey Golden: highly considered ...
[00:12:06] Kelly Goetsch: or highly considered. Right. There's not a lot
[00:12:08] Ricardo Belmar: Not a lot the middle.
[00:12:09] Kelly Goetsch: in between. . I think we've solved the unconsidered stuff.
[00:12:10] You know- we do Walmart home delivery, it's great!
[00:12:12] Ricardo Belmar: Yep.
[00:12:13] Kelly Goetsch: Amazon subscribe and save. we get our 10 boxes every month.
[00:12:16] Ricardo Belmar: Mm-hmm.
[00:12:16] Kelly Goetsch: Super solved problem for considered purchases.
[00:12:19] I don't... But a lot of people are, I think, mistakenly saying "I don't want my AI to, you know, buy my next suit for me," and I agree.
[00:12:26] I think that's a terrible use case.
[00:12:27] Casey Golden: I,
[00:12:27] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah
[00:12:27] Casey Golden: that's a terrible use case
[00:12:29] Kelly Goetsch: I think it's very valuable to " say, Okay. Well, i'm going, here in the summer. what type of fabric would be better?"
[00:12:35] Mm-hmm.
[00:12:36] Right? Yeah. give me a lowdown on, you know, ......linen versus a, a worsted wool. Which would be better for this, right? And then give some ideas.
[00:12:44] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:12:44] Kelly Goetsch: So see that as being quite valuable.
[00:12:46] Casey Golden: Yeah.
[00:12:47] Ricardo Belmar: that makes sense.
[00:12:48] Yeah, I can't disagree with that.
[00:12:49] Casey Golden: No.
[00:12:50] Where have you been?
[00:12:52] How am I just now meeting you today? I've had a somebody on my
[00:12:56] Ricardo Belmar: before.
[00:12:57] Casey Golden: Soapbox.
[00:12:58] Kelly Goetsch: I feel a little, get off [00:13:00] my lawn- ..............................sometimes, You I
[00:13:01] Casey Golden: Oh, I feel that the same? Yeah. Oh, I feel that all the time. So now,
[00:13:03] I... I... We're, we've got, we're- power with numbers.
[00:13:05] Ricardo Belmar: Long lost souls here. I
[00:13:06] Kelly Goetsch: know. Yeah. look, I mean, if you just step back and look at where we are right now, this is peak hype, peak everything. We're gonna look back on this- ...in a year or two and
[00:13:14] Casey Golden: oh!
[00:13:14] Kelly Goetsch: you know, we're all,you know, eating off the streets.
[00:13:16] Casey Golden: so adorable.
[00:13:17] Kelly Goetsch: Yeah. You know?
[00:13:17] Ricardo Belmar: Right.
[00:13:18] Right.
[00:13:18] Kelly Goetsch: It's like, oh, they were so optimistic."
[00:13:20] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:13:20] Casey Golden: I know.
[00:13:20] Kelly Goetsch: So-
[00:13:21] What Shoppers Will Do With AI This Holiday Season
[00:13:21] Ricardo Belmar: Do you have a, Do you have a prediction for you think we're gonna see consumers doing with AI for the holidays?
[00:13:26] Kelly Goetsch: A lot of shopping on ChatGPT. ChatGPT specifically.
[00:13:30] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah ...
[00:13:31] Kelly Goetsch: is great. I don't see, Anthropic with Claude making much of a move in commerce.
[00:13:35] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:13:36] Casey Golden: And I hope they don't, really.
[00:13:37] Kelly Goetsch: Yeah, I don't so. I don't,
[00:13:38] Casey Golden: I don't think that's, I don't think that's the best place for it. You know? I think, I think Gemini is definitely set up to do a lot of shopping, They have a lot of Google- shopping ... shopping feeds. I think it could be a lot better, you know? It could be. but I mean, speaking of boomers, my mom is- ... a regular [00:14:00] conversation with ChatGPT now.
[00:14:01] Kelly Goetsch: My mother-in-law is as well
[00:14:02]
[00:14:02] Casey Golden: my mom didn't know that Gemini was a Google AI.
[00:14:06] So but she-
[00:14:07] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah ...
[00:14:07] Casey Golden: she learned about chatGPT, and hm I get three less phone call a day
[00:14:13] Ricardo Belmar: There's a positive there.
[00:14:14] Kelly Goetsch: AI daughter now. Instead of the AI boyfriend, it's the AI daughter.
[00:14:16] Casey Golden: Exactly, I guess so.
[00:14:18] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I said but there's a positive advantage
[00:14:21] Casey Golden: Yeah ... that is Yeah. I think we gotta divide to conquer here.
[00:14:25] Ricardo Belmar: Mm-hmm.
[00:14:26] Casey Golden: Mm-hmm.
[00:14:26] Everything yeah ...does not need to be about commerce and shopping- as much
[00:14:29] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:14:30] Casey Golden: I love commerce and shopping.
[00:14:32] Kelly Goetsch: Well, we're at ...the center of ...the universe right now- We're in... now. We're, yeah, Yeah, in the world- right, In the... Right. ...
[00:14:35] Right right. We're agentic commerce.
[00:14:36] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah. That's right. That's right.
[00:14:38] But I don't know. I th-
[00:14:39] Why Google Will Lose Agentic Commerce
[00:14:41] Ricardo Belmar: I guess my last thought on that one is, even for Google, right, this is what? Google's sixth attempt at doing something around this to, quote, " redo commerce."
[00:14:46]
[00:14:47] Ricardo Belmar: at least. I've lost track, and I can't say that any of the previous ones were that impressive since the original Froogle.
[00:14:53] Kelly Goetsch: Mm-hmm.
[00:14:54] Ricardo Belmar: So maybe this one will work, but i... there's certainly potential .
[00:14:57] I don't see a lot of cases of, UCP adoption [00:15:00] from them, but, we still don't have a universal cart. I think that was the one I asked, I don't know how many episodes back. I said, "
[00:15:05] When are we getting that universal cart across- yeah ... merchant? But there's so many issues with trying to pull that off. I don't know that, I think we keep seeing that,
[00:15:11] Casey Golden: the,
[00:15:12] Ricardo Belmar: these aI tech companies trying solve commerce but don't actually talk to commerce people before they put something out
[00:15:17] Kelly Goetsch: Or employ any commerce people that matter
[00:15:19] Casey Golden: employ too.
[00:15:20] Kelly Goetsch: Would help.
[00:15:21] Ricardo Belmar: Yeah.
[00:15:22] Casey Golden: Yeah.
[00:15:22] Ricardo Belmar: Right
[00:15:22] Kelly Goetsch: I, I don't see... I honestly don't see Google
[00:15:25] Casey Golden: not a lot of retail people building tech in the first place.
[00:15:27] Kelly Goetsch: They're not
[00:15:28] I don't see Google winning this one- ... because Google makes a fundamental mistake, which is they confuse buying for shopping.
[00:15:34] Casey Golden: Yes.
[00:15:35] Ricardo Belmar: That's right.
[00:15:35] Yeah. That's true.
[00:15:36] Kelly Goetsch: And I think those are two different things
[00:15:38] Casey Golden: Yeah, Kelly you're so on my team.
[00:15:40] Kelly Goetsch: People want to shop, and right now you see a pixel of an image yeah ...and ... five words. People don't buy off of that.
[00:15:49] Casey Golden: No. Right.. So you just remember earlier this morning at Rick Watson's debate, I voted for you
[00:15:55] Kelly Goetsch: I didn't actually vote for you. You did well, though.
[00:15:57] Ricardo Belmar: There we go.
[00:15:58] Kelly Goetsch: You were dealt a tough hand on that one.
[00:15:59] Ricardo Belmar: [00:16:00] All right. Well, Kelly, thank you so much for joining us.
[00:16:02] Kelly Goetsch: Thank you.
[00:16:02] Ricardo Belmar: This great conversation.
[00:16:03] I know Casey's gonna be talking about this one for months to come.
[00:16:05] Casey Golden: Yes. Absolute pleasure.
[00:16:07] Kelly Goetsch: Likewise.
[00:16:08] Casey Golden: Enjoy the rest of the conference.
[00:16:10] Kelly Goetsch: Thanks, You guys too.
[00:16:11] Ricardo Belmar: Thanks again
[00:16:13]
[00:16:13] Show Close
[00:16:18] Casey Golden: I know you loved this episode, so drop us a five-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Goodpods. And if you're watching us on YouTube, like and subscribe before you go.
[00:16:30] I'm Casey Golden.
[00:16:31] Ricardo Belmar: Follow us on LinkedIn, Bluesky Threads, and Instagram, and subscribe to our Substack for highlights and bonus content. For transcripts and guest info, visit retailrazor.com.
[00:16:41] I'm Ricardo Belmar.
[00:16:42] Casey Golden: Thanks for joining us on Retail Transformers, part of the Retail Razor Podcast Network
[00:16:47] Ricardo Belmar: Until next time, stay sharp, be bold, and keep transforming retail.
[00:16:51] This is the Retail Razor: Retail Transformers!




